Hermetica Superfood Co.
The clearest difference is the formula: Hush pairs a small melatonin serving with L-theanine, reishi and passionflower; Natrol’s 5 mg strawberry gummy is a melatonin-only active formula. Hush contains 0.35 mg of melatonin per one-gummy serving. Choose Hush if that lower labeled amount and a concord-grape gummy appeal to you.
Hush is $32 for one tin or $84 for three tins. The comparison below uses Natrol Melatonin 5 mg Gummies specifically, so you can compare two defined products rather than an entire brand.
Swipe the table to compare all columns →
| Compare | Hush | Natrol Melatonin 5 mg Gummies |
|---|---|---|
| Melatonin and serving | 0.35 mg per one-gummy labeled serving | 5 mg per labeled serving |
| Gummy count per labeled serving | 1 gummy | 1 gummy |
| Formula highlights | Includes melatonin, L-theanine, reishi and passionflower | Melatonin; no additional botanical active listed in the displayed facts panel |
| Flavor and format | Concord-grape gummies in a cream tin | Strawberry |
| One-time purchase price | $32 one tin; $84 three tins | Sold through retailers; price varies |
| Consider it for | A small labeled melatonin serving with reishi, L-theanine and passionflower | A melatonin-only active formula in a one-gummy serving |
Source: Natrol Melatonin 5 mg Gummies official product page, checked October 4, 2026.
What to compare beyond the melatonin number
Both are gummies, but the labeled amounts differ. Hush’s one-gummy serving contains 0.35 mg of melatonin. The selected Natrol product lists 5 mg in one gummy.
The useful shopping question is which formula you are looking for. Some shoppers want melatonin on its own; others want a gummy that includes mushroom and botanical ingredients.
If you have been looking for a lower-melatonin option, Hush belongs on your shortlist. If you prefer a melatonin-only active formula, this Natrol product is the more direct match.
The flavor and formula are Hush’s distinction. Concord-grape gummies bring melatonin together with L-theanine, reishi and passionflower in a cream tin.
Compare the amount per labeled serving. Both labeled servings here are one gummy, and the melatonin amounts differ: 0.35 mg in Hush and 5 mg in the selected Natrol product.
The rest of the Hush formula
The selected Natrol panel lists melatonin as its active ingredient. Hush includes additional named ingredients for shoppers looking for a multi-ingredient evening formula.
Three ingredients that help distinguish the Hush formula are:
L-theanine
L-theanine is an amino acid also found in tea. Hush includes it alongside melatonin in the same gummy formula.
Reishi
A functional mushroom included in Hush. If mushroom products interest you more broadly, our Eternity Mushroom Gummies offer another format to explore.
Passion flower
Passionflower is one of the botanicals included in Hush. It is part of the combination that differentiates Hush from the selected melatonin-only Natrol formula.
That gives you a practical choice: Hush for a grape-flavored formula with these additional ingredients, or the selected Natrol product if you want melatonin as the only listed active.
A format that fits your preferences
Hush’s labeled serving is one gummy, and so is the selected Natrol serving. Keep those units together with the melatonin figures when comparing the products.
For everyday convenience, both are ready-to-take gummies. Your preference for concord grape or strawberry may be an easier decision than the packaging makes it seem.
A simple first choice: one tin of Hush. At $32, it lets you try the flavor and format without choosing a multi-tin order.
What the available testing covers
Available independent reports for a December 2025 Hush sample cover heavy metals, microbes and residual solvents.
The comparison focuses on product facts: labeled melatonin, format, named ingredients and purchase options. A lower amount does not by itself establish better sleep or a particular next-morning experience.
How it fits an actual evening
Make room for an evening that feels less crowded: finish one small task, put tomorrow’s essentials together and leave a little time to unwind.
A supplement can be one part of a broader routine. If you also enjoy a warm drink, explore Cozy adaptogenic chai as a separate option in the Hermetica range.
For the wider view, our 2026 sleep gummy guide maps the category, and the natural sleep support guide covers the habits that do the heavy lifting no supplement can replace.
Current prices and purchase options
Hush costs $32 for one tin or $84 for three tins, before any applicable shipping or tax. The three-tin option saves $12 compared with buying three single tins at $32 each. Prices checked October 4, 2026.
Natrol directs shoppers to retailers, so compare the actual retailer price with the Hush option you want. Subscription choices are also available for Hush if repeat delivery suits you.
Concord-grape gummies with 0.35 mg melatonin per one-gummy serving, plus L-theanine, reishi and passionflower. One tin $32; three tins $84.
Product details and prices checked October 4, 2026. Formulas may vary by version; amounts alone do not establish comparative sleep results. Hermetica is not affiliated with the other brand. If you are pregnant or nursing, take medication or have a medical condition, consult a healthcare professional before use. These statements have not been evaluated by the FDA. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease.
Connected Reading & Ingredient Hub
Explore related sleep research, brand comparisons, and ingredient guides
Common Questions
How much melatonin is in a serving of Hush?
What is the main formula difference?
Which Hush option can I buy?
What does Hush taste like?
Does a lower melatonin amount guarantee better sleep?
Which competitor product is compared here?
How do the Hush bundle prices compare?
Pairs Well With This Article
Functional mushroom gummies from the Hermetica range. Explore the current product details and options.
Shilajit gummies from the Hermetica range. Explore the current product details and options.
Marine collagen from the Hermetica range. Explore the current product details and options.
Relevant Articles
Continue Reading
How to Fall Asleep Faster: Evidence-Based Techniques That Actually Help
Protein Supplements For Hair Growth: The Evidence-Based Guide for 2026
Chamomile, Passionflower, and the Ancient Botanicals That Actually Work for Sleep
Why People Choose Hermetica